Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth., Fl. Austral. 1: 400 (1863) (syn: Catha montana (Roth) G.Don; Celastrus buxifolius var. laxiflorus Kuntze ; Celastrus montanus Roth; Celastrus montanus Roxb. ; Staphylea montana Roxb. ex Wight & Arn.);
.
W. India, Bangladesh: Bangladesh, India, Myanmar as per POWO:
.
Common name: Mountain Spike Thorn • Kannada: ತಂದ್ರಾಸಿ Tandrasi, ತಂಡರಸಿ Tandarasi, kankada, ಕಂಗೊಂದಿ Kangondi, ತನಸಿ Tanasi • Sanskrit: Vikankala, Vikankar, Vyaghrapadi • Tamil: kattangi • Telugu: chinni, dantansi, dante
.
This shrub has already been discussed earlier. Flowers are hermaphrodite. Five sepals and petals. Plant armed with thorn like branches on which leaves and flowers grow.
Has started flowering on Vetal Tekdi (29.10.09). Earlier I had to search the plant but since I have known it I could spot it at number of places on Vetal Tekdi Pune Shot today 29thOct 2009.
Very few shrubs were in full flowers; rest are having buds at present
As per GRIN, Maytenus senegalensis is a synonym of Gymnosporia senegalensis. The base name is Celastrus senegalensis.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Pl. find the attached file conatin photos for id. request.
Habit: Tree
This is a species of Maytenus possibly M.senegalensis.
Yes Maytenus senegalensis.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Attached herewith photos of a profusely flowering tree.
Location – Satara
The tree resembles with Ziziphus (Marathi-Bor)
Leaves – Normal thick
Tree – 15 feet tall
Flowers – small 6- 10 mm
Time- Nov-2008
This looks like Celastraceae sp. Check for Maytenus senegalensis.
Yes it is Maytenus senegalensis
Celastraceae
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Celastraceae fortnight :: Maytenus senegalensis. Pune SMP2 : 1 post by 1 author. 3 images.
Maytenus senegalensis. Vetal Tekdi Pune
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
ID Please
A tree at Lonar sarovar,Buldhana
23 Feb,2014
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Elaeodendron glaucum : Attachments (7). 14 posts by 5 authors.
Affirmative.
Certainly a great specimen of Elaeodendron glaucum from Celastraceae family !
Very nice flowers.
Serrated margins of the leaves also seen
Let’s wait for experts comments.
& Forest Flora of A.P.:
Both the plants are from family Celastraceae so the flowers are bound to be similar looking.
Were the branches terminating into flower and leaf bearing spines?
I may be wrong and open for discussion. I still feel it to be Elaeodendron glaucum.
The points in its favour.
The picture appears to be of a small tree rather than a shrub. The calyx lobes are deeply divided. We might get some opinions…..
These photos are from Elaeodendron. In Elaeodendron the ovary and disk are continuous and with the stamens arising from the top of the disk, never from the outside (much like Salacia etc.). You can see that clearly from the flower in front. In Gymnosporia the disk is separate and the stamens are from outside the disk.
In continuation with this interesting thread…………..
I again visited the area and could find some of these Maytenus senegalensis shrubs in full bloom. On rethinking the plant posted by … appears to be Maytenus (Gymnosporia) senegalensis only. The pictures I posted in the thread are of Elaeodendron glaucum plant which is also near these plants.
Attaching new pictures of Maytenus senegalensis flowers clicked 2 hrs back.
The features I observed from both.
Maytenus senegalensis : Inflorescences too many….almost full plant in most. Thorny branches but not always. Leaves comparatively smaller. Size of the plant in my observation not more than 10 feet.
Elaeodendron glaucum : Inflorescence occasional at one time(Total 3 big sized were present on full plant. Leaves comparatively larger and often folded to some extent on the midvein. Size of the plant 15 feet or more.
… has already given the very distinct differentiating feature.
Will try to observe the fruits which are characteristic in both.
What possibly I ignored most in the first instance was the white colour of my plant compared to the light green of the petals of Elaeodendron glaucum, which were also thinner compared to those of Elaeodendron glaucum.
May Dr. Archer sort out the things now.
Sorry to come in so late. Was at a Marine Bio-diversity Camp in the Gulf of Kutch.
It is definitely not Cassine glauca [Elaeodendron glaucum]. It is a Meytenus sp.- most likely M.senegalensis.
What would you like to say of no spines seen on the branches/ tree etc. in my plant?
On some smaller shrubs spines are not always present. You have consider the larger picture.
I check all my original pictures (around 12) of two different trees, one of them a large one. I didn’t get any hint of spines in these.
Coming back with computer problems… I sent the pictures to Marie Jordaan, who is currently revising the genus Gymnosporia. She feels the name Gymnosporia montana should be applied to these. It is often that thorns are absent from tree.
As we are currently using Gymnosporia senegalensis is a African species that occur up to Pakistan and possibly in India. The other species of Gymnosporia occurring in Southern India and Sri Lanka is Gymnosporia emarginata, a species that extend to Australia.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Plant for ID : (mixed thread)- 2 correct images.
Attached herewith photographs of a flowering tree for ID. Photo taken at Satara in November.
… Calycopteris floribunda, paper-flower climber … ( झाल jhaal, उक्षी ukshi in Marathi )
in Flickr
The leaves of this specimen are unlike the leaves of Calycopteris sp. This one looks more like a Rhamnaceae member.
… flowers too !! Thanks … I think I jumped awkwardly !!!!!! Please disregard Calycopteris floribunda
It is a Cassine spp. possibly C. paniculata. Haven’t got photographs of C.paniculata but am sending you photographs of C.glauca [locally called Bhutuxia] for comparison. The photographs were taken at Shahapur.
it seems to be Henkal – Maytenus senegalensis – if it was a shrub. Flowers & leaves seem to be of henkal. What about thorns ?
for me it looks like a species of Gymnosporia (= Maytenus), most probably G. ovata.
Spent a morning with Dr.Almeida.
It’s Maytenus senegalensis. Kudos to Ketaki / Manasi for getting this right.
In view of the following reply from Dr. Archer in thread, we should now take it as Gymnosporia montana:
“Coming back with computer problems… I sent the pictures to Marie Jordaan, who is currently revising the genus Gymnosporia. She feels the name Gymnosporia montana should be applied to these. It is often that thorns are absent from tree.
As we are currently using Gymnosporia senegalensis is a African species that occur up to Pakistan and possibly in India. The other species of Gymnosporia occurring in Southern India and Sri Lanka is Gymnosporia emarginata, a species that extend to Australia.
According to Dr.Almeida’s ‘Flora of Mahareashtra’ Vol 1, page 243 – Maytenus senegalensisis the new name for Gymnosporia montana/ Gymnosporia emarginata.
The genus Gymnosporia has been very problematic in the past and it is unfortunately very confusing. I hope somebody will put up photos of proper G. senegalensis and G. emarginata from the North West and South India respectively.
Flaucourtia montana: Attachments (5). 2 posts by 2 authors.
Flaucourtia montana
Please validate
Slip on the genus, it is Gymnosporia montana, of Celastraceae, syn of Maytenus senegalensis. Henkal in marathi.
Farmlands adjoining Bannerghatta National Park
August 2014
Bangalore
Gymnosporia wallichiana M.A.Lawson (= Maytenus wallichiana (Spreng.) D.C.S. Raju & Babu), Celastraceae
Gymnosporia montana, perhaps.
Gymnosporia montana. The plant is common in the shrub jungles of the Mysore city outskirts.
It is my pleasure to share few images of Gymnosporia montana (Celastraceae)
http://florakarnataka.ces.iisc.ernet.in/hjcb2/herbsheet.php?id=1075&cat=1
Habit: Shrub
Habitat: Scrub forests
Sighting: Chikmagalur, Karnataka, about 900 msl
Date: 24-11-2014, 15-12-2014, 02-02-2015, 22-02-2015 and 09-11-2015
Thank you …,
I am requesting all to kindly enlighten me in this regard.
Thanks … for your feed back. I am afraid that I may not be of any help but for supplying you the field images…! Kindly do not hesitate… and seek field info…I am very much willing to go around and collect the same.
Thanks, …, If you pursue earlier discussions at Gymnosporia emarginata & Gymnosporia montana, you may get some clues.
Thanks …, The question remains to be solved, especially because the treatment for Flora of India does not cite the name ‘montana’ even as a synonym. A thorough search preferably by an expert is necessary.
May I request … to pl. clarify in this matter, if possible.
I hope this help,
I am grateful to you … for the clarification. I think now we have to change and apply the correct nomenclature for the Indian species.
I could say this by looking at the leaf margin. Thank you.
Maytenus are plants without thorns and is currently only applied to the plants of South America.
As per my knowledge, the third photo should be of Gymnosporia montana, though the leaves are emarginate at apex but they appear to be be more than 4 cm in length and clearly petiolate. G. emarginata has smaller, subsessile leaves. … had already clarified the differences between the closely related South Indian species and that the genus Meytenus does not occur in India.
Saw this plant flowering on the rim of the Lonar lake, Buldana MH in December 2016.
Many plants were profusely flowering. These match the images posted by Pravin ji from the same location and posted on eFI.
Please validate it as Gymnosporia senegalensis
Thanks, …, for superb images with complete set.
maytenus emarginata
Thanks, … To me it appears more closer to Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. as per images & details herein.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
Identification, please. Gymnosporia spinosa?
Date/Time- November 4, 2017; 12:23 hrs.
Location- Place, Altitude, GPS- Eastern Melghat; 21°17.483′ N, 77°22.530′ E
Habitat- Garden/ Urban/ Wild/ Type- Wild
Plant Habit- Tree/ Shrub/ Climber/ Herb- Shrub/Tree
Height/Length- 6-7’ Height
Thanks, …, There are five different species with this name as per Catalogue of Life.
Your appears close to images and details at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. (syn. Gymnosporia senegalensis var. spinosa Engl. ex Loes.) as per comparative images at Gymnosporia
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
ID please?: 3 images.
I think this may Gymnosporia senegalensis or Gymnosporia montana, but not sure, ??
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
On Mhotaba Tekadi we have seen saplings, are these saplings of Gymnosporia senegalensis ?
4 high resolution images.
Yes, appears so as per images and details at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
Shrub for ID : Nasik : 23MAR21 : AK-05: 3 images.
Shrub seen in a field in Nasik a few days ago (23.3.21)
Is Pyracantha crenulata (D.Don) M.Roem. recorded in Maharashtra ?
This does not look like Pyracantha to me.
Pl. post high resolution of the1st image. Maybe Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Adding the images. 3 high resolution images.
Yes, Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
,
Malhargad near Pune, MH :: Gymnosporia senegalensis for validation :: ARK2021-052: 5 images.
Saw this large shrub/tree at Malhargad near Pune in July 2021 on a small hillock.
Identified as Gymnosporia senegalensis.
Requested to please validate.
I guess ID is correct !
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
Shrub for ID : Nasik : 20JAN22 : AK – 31: 5 images.
Shrub seen on the mountain slope at the base of Borgad Conservation Reserve (20.1.22?).
Kindly validate.
Yes, appears close to images at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
Need ID: shrub w/ segmented fruit: 2 images.
Lower Himalayas
May 2022
Pl. check https://efloraofindia.com/2011/03/03/gymnospora/
To me appears close to images at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Pl. always mention where in the lower Himalayas?
It helps saving time and energy in ids and proper id.
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV384: 4 images.
Many thanks to Alex Y. for validating the ID at iNaturalis
.
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV387: 8 images.
Many thanks to Alex Y. for validating the ID at iNaturalist
ID corrected to Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. by Ajay Mondal ji in iNaturalist.
Can you ask him what the differences between the two?
I have quoted Ajay Mondal ji’s response in another post –https://groups.google.com/g/indiantreepix/c/oP8CuGe4qmo/m/DJAONd6lCQAJ
.
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV392: 3 images.
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes.
Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · 2:58 PM IST :: about 14 m (46 ft) asl
ID corrected to Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. by Ajay Mondal ji in iNaturalist.
AI view gives the following difference:
Gymnosporia montana and Gymnosporia senegalensis are closely related spiny shrubs or small trees in the Celastraceae family. The primary difference lies in their leaf size, shape, and geographic distribution, with G. montana featuring larger, broader leaves and a more localized range in southern India compared to the widely distributed, narrower-leaved G. senegalensis. [1, 2, 3, 4]
- Distribution: Found mainly in southern India and the Western Ghats.
- Leaves: Larger and broader in shape compared to its relative.
- Distribution: Widespread across tropical and South Africa, extending to Pakistan and northwestern India.
- Leaves: Usually narrower, pale blue-green or glaucous with a whitish bloom.
- Leaf Breadth: G. montana has broader and larger leaves; G. senegalensis has narrower leaves.
,
Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394: 9 images.
Many thanks to Alex Y. for validating the ID at iNaturalist
ID corrected to Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. by Ajay Mondal ji in iNaturalist.
Can you ask himwhat the differences between the two?
I had asked Ajay Mondal ji the same query when he suggested / corrected the ID of my Shirgaon (Palghar) observations.
I am quoting his response in iNaturalist mail dated 7 Aug 01:02 PM, is as follows:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In my opinion, these are distinct species. Gymnosporia montana can be recognized by its obovate to elliptic leaves (whereas populations from Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh often have suborbicular leaves), crenate leaf margins, and subglobose, trilocular fruits.
G. montana is also frequently confused with the strictly drier Eastern Ghats species, Gymnosporia emarginata, which is common in Andhra Pradesh, Odisha, and the drier parts of Tamil Nadu. However, G. emarginata can be readily distinguished by its entire leaf margins and turbinate or pyriform to triangular, distinctly three-lobed fruits.
Based on my observations, plants corresponding to G. senegalensis are confined to northwestern India, particularly Rajasthan and Punjab, and I have not encountered typical G. senegalensis elsewhere in the country.
.
Celastraceae: Gymnosporia parviflora subsp. parviflora: 1 image.
synonyms: Catha parviflora, Catha spinosa Forsk., Celastrus parviflorus, Gymnosporia spinosa, Gymnosporia spinosa, Maytenus parviflora
location/date: Chotannahalli, Tumkur Dist., Karnataka, July 1997
Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as per discussions at Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. :: Shirgaon, Palghar :: Feb 26, 2023 · JUN23 DV394
.
.
References:
POWO WFO GBIF (High resolution specimens) Flora of Gandhinagar Flora of Pakistan Flora of peninsular India Flowers of India India Biodiversity Portal Wikimedia Commons
References for Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth.:
Catalogue of Life The Plant List GRIN
Flora of Pakistan (Maytenus senegalensis (Lam.) Exell with Catha montana (Roth) G.Don, Celastrus montanus Roth, Roem. & Schult., Celastrus senegalensis Lam., Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. & Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. as synonyms)
Flora Zambesiaca (Maytenus senegalensis (Lam.) Exell with Catha montana (Roth) G. Don, Celastrus montanus Roth apud Roem. & Schult., Celastrus senegalensis Lam., Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth., Gymnosporia senegalensis (Lam.) Loes. etc. as syn. among others)
Flora of Davanagere District: Karnataka, India By B. K. Manjunatha, V. Krishna, T. Pullaiah (Keys- Maytenus emarginata & rothiana & Description) (Maytenus emarginata (Willd.) Ding Hou with Celastrus emarginatus Willd., Celastrus montanus Roth, Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Bentham & Gymnosporia emarginata (Willd.) Thwaites as syn.)
Flora of Madhya Pradesh: Chhatarpur and Damoh By G. P. Roy, B. K. Shukla, Bhaskar Datt (Maytenus emarginata (Willd.) Ding Hou with Gymnosporia montana (Roth) Benth. as syn.)
.























