Strobilanthes carnatica

Strobilanthes carnatica Carine, J.M.Alexander & Scotland;
.
India (Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka) as per Catalogue of Life;
.


idwntification of strobilantes sp: 2 high res. images.
Pl help me to identify the strobilanthes sp observed in Yelagiri Hills, at about 800 ft, MSL

Could not find a match as per comparative images at
https://efloraofindia.com/2011/03/20/strobilanthes/

I am afraid I don’t know the Indian peninsular species so well and I can’t identify this. I can say many species that it isn’t but that is not very helpful, I am afraid.

Strobilanthes carnatica

Does it not look different from images at
https://efloraofindia.com/2020/03/27/strobilanthes-carnatica/?

But it is without doubt S carnatica …. I dont know the correct id of the other images you shown to me. Of course, that would be fit more akin to S consanguinea? It is a complex species

/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/DSC01852.JPG
Here i am sending photos of strobilanthus species collected from chittor district of andhra Pradesh : 17 posts by 6 authors. Attachments (2)- around 650 kb each.
Please identify the stobilanthus species

Strobilanthes consanguineus ??

Looks different from images at Strobilanthes consanguinea
Could not find a match as per comparative images at Strobilanthes
This is Strobilanthes canarica

I agree that it doesn’t look right for S. consanguinea but I don’t know the South Indian species very well so am reluctant to suggest an alternative. S. consanguinea is said to be quite variable.

To me looks different from Strobilanthes canarica per specimens in GBIF and publication at Download PDF – Journal of Threatened Taxa
It looks different. Not S. canarica for sure. It is found only in higher altitudes. Iet me see more images, also the habitat, habit etc. Some times a new one
Oh I am sorry, this is of course not S. canarica, it is S. carnatica
Thanks, … Here is the GBIF Specimen.
it resembles Strobilanthes meeboldii
Thanks, …
It is S. carnatica as confirmed by … and as per GBIF Specimen and as per A Revision of the Strobilanthes kunthiana-Group (Phlebophyllum sensu Bremekamp) (Acanthaceae) by Mark A. Carine and others- Kew Bulletin 59(1):1–25 · January 2004 (Abstract- Morphological variation in the Strobilanthes kunthiana group is examined and species delimitation problems addressed. A taxonomic revision is presented recognising ten species from peninsular India. Two new species are described, Strobilanthes gamblei Carine, J. Alexander & Scotland and S. carnatica Carine, J. Alexander & Scotland).
I could not get any images or specimen of Strobilanthes meeboldii on net including on GBIF. Also it is not distributed in the posted area.

Sending you the publication by Carine.

I had gone through the doc, sometimes not very common specimens may not be included in the review articles; I feel the review articles are not final/supreme; further another article may be published with the additions as sub-species etc, when there is substantiated  evidence that our specimen differs with them by young enthusiastic people like Anjaneyulu

Thank you so much for your explanation, …,
…, we have earlier reports from the posted area….look into the references, please…
Attachments (2)
Please dissect flowers and provide some information about plant profile,
hope that will help for conformation,

 

.

References:
Catalogue of Life   GBIF Specimen  IBIS Flora

A Revision of the Strobilanthes kunthiana-Group (Phlebophyllum sensu Bremekamp) (Acanthaceae) by Mark A. Carine and others- Kew Bulletin 59(1):1–25 · January 2004

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *